@article{oai:ynu.repo.nii.ac.jp:00009378,
 author = {Hatsuse, Takumi and Nakazaki, Nobuya and Tsuda, Hirotaka and Takao, Yoshinori and Eriguchi, Koji and Ono, Kouichi},
 issue = {14},
 journal = {Journal of Applied Physics},
 month = {Oct},
 note = {Plasma-induced surface roughening and ripple formation has been studied based on Monte Carlo simulations of plasma-surface interactions and feature profile evolution during Si etching in Cl-based plasmas, with emphasis being placed on the role and effects of ion reflection from microstructural feature surfaces on incidence. The simulation model included the effects of Cl+ ion reflection (and/or its penetration into substrates) through calculating the momentum and energy conservation in successive two-body elastic collisions with substrate Si atoms every ion incidence. The “reflection coefficient ri” was then further introduced in the model (0 ≤ ri ≤ 1), representing the fraction of ions incident on surfaces with the reflection/penetration calculation scheme turned on. The coefficient ri is, in a sense, a measure of the reflection probability for impacts of an ion species onto Si surfaces relative to that for Cl+ impacts. Simulations for ion incidence angles of θi = 0°, 45°, and 75° onto substrate surfaces with incident energies in the range Ei = 20−500 eV showed that as ri is slightly decreased from unity, the roughness decreases substantially, and the ripple formation fades away: the roughness remains at the low level of stochastic roughening during etching for decreased ri ≤ ri* ≈ 0.95−0.75 (the critical ri* tends to be lower at higher Ei and θi) with no ripple structures at off-normal θi. This elucidates that the ion reflection is indispensable in surface roughening and rippling during plasma etching, and their degree relies significantly on the reflectivity of ions. Simulations further showed that at intermediate off-normal θi = 45°, the ripple wavelength increases significantly with decreasing ri, while the increase in amplitude is relatively less significant; thus, sawtooth-like ripple profiles pronounced for ri = 1 tend to be collapsed with decreasing ri. These effects of reduced ion reflection on plasma-induced surface roughening and ripple formation are discussed in terms of effectively enhanced smoothing due to neutral reactants, which competes with the roughening and rippling caused by ion bombardment.},
 pages = {143301-1--143301-14},
 title = {Origin of plasma-induced surface roughening and ripple formation during plasma etching: The crucial role of ion reflection},
 volume = {124},
 year = {2018}
}